Skip to content
Sign in

The questions that tell you more than counting units

Counting is easy to lose and easy to fool. These are not.

Lesson 2 of 4

10 min Text

What this lesson says

  • No level of drinking has been established as beneficial; less is better
  • Ask what it is doing rather than how much it is
  • Whether you can predict how an evening will end is a more useful question than the quantity
  • Other people noticing is data, not nagging
  • Drinking to steady yourself in the morning is a specific and important signal

This is general education. It is not advice about your own situation, and it does not replace seeing a clinician.

Written lesson.
  1. 1. Counting units is a poor tool in practice. Indian measures are not standard, home pours are generous, nobody counts accurately at the time, and the arithmetic is easy to argue with the next day. A better set of questions is about effect and control.
  2. 2. Before them, one piece of context. The honest current position is that no level of alcohol has been established as beneficial, and the older reporting suggesting a small benefit has not held up well under better analysis. Less is better, and that is the whole of the guidance.
  3. 3. The first question: what is it doing? Sleep, weight, blood pressure, mood, money, and the hours after. If you have been tired for months and you drink most evenings, you have a testable hypothesis and the test takes three weeks.
  4. 4. The second: can you predict how an evening will go? Setting out to have two and having six is a more meaningful observation than the number six. So is finding that you cannot easily stop once you have started, or that you drink faster than the people around you.
  5. 5. The third: has anybody else noticed? Family commenting, a partner asking, work being affected, a friend making a joke that was not entirely a joke — people around you see a pattern you are inside of. Their observation is data rather than nagging, even when it is delivered badly.
  6. 6. The fourth, and the most specific: do you drink in the morning, or feel that you need one to steady yourself, or get shaky, sweaty or anxious when you have not had one for a while? That is a different question from the other three and it matters for the last lesson of this course, because it changes how stopping should be done.
  7. 7. None of these questions decides anything by itself. What they do is give you something concrete to say to a clinician, which is considerably more useful than a number you have estimated downwards.

All lessons in this course

  1. 1 What alcohol does to the liver, and how quietly it does it 11 min
  2. 2 The questions that tell you more than counting units 10 min Reading now
  3. 3 Liver tests, and what a normal result does not rule out 11 min
  4. 4 Cutting down, stopping, and when stopping needs supervision 10 min

No lesson is locked. Ticks appear once you have an account, so that what you have read is yours and not this device's.